Wigner, Casey Blood, J. Namely, tangent vectors x,y,z,t to this point are identified with Hermitian forms on E with matrix. Obscurantism Anti-Platonism Deny the amazing efficiency of mathematics observed in physics; stay ignorant about it. Idiots give him high rates, not that they love his essay, but because they love him. What matters is the opportunity for sane people, able to define the right standards, to get information filtered according to their own standard. Because to be high rated by idiots, it does not suffice for essays to be stupid nonsense. But the essay of Philip Gibbs does not have this “quality”.
Of course some essays have well-deserved very low rating. See my comments there As I noted there, that article has some points, but also some flaws , and in my Web page on the topic. This equation describes the field of electronic presence as taking values in the space of bispinors of space-time. Because naively implemented, such a method will fail in a world with a ratio of 10 idiots for 1 competent reviewer, as long as no system is developed for people to automatically filter the information depending on the competence of the reviewer. Here are the explanations. Idiots give him high rates, not that they love his essay, but because they love him.
Robert Spekkens wins first prize in FQXi essay contest
As for the remarkable role of maths in physics: Indeed, relativistic filters are all what technical systems can do anyway: Confest, he argues, the distinction is artificial, and only a kind of union of kinematics and dynamics has a bearing on the predictions of the model. Because average humans who “care” often have a big bias for obscurantism i. For more information, contact: GribEuan Squires?
Mathematical Universe Hypothesis mathematical monism QM: So to be workable, an open peer review system fqxo also need a kind of filter, to let anyone filter the measure of reviews according to his own standards. SinghTorsten Asselmeyer-Maluga. Now what is amazing with the success of mathematics is that this spinor space Esswy was found to be “what electrons and other fermions are actually made of”.
Idiots give him high rates, not that they love his essay, but because they love him. Not only this, but I also cared to make the most serious, accurate and developed comments to many essays – I did not find anyone else writing such serious and elaborate comments as I did. Wigner, Casey Blood, J.
Robert Spekkens wins first prize in FQXi essay contest | Perimeter Institute
Then is also a clash between the cells of the Obscurantism column. HitterdaleRoger SchlaflyPaul Merriam.
Concretely, a big problem with a spinor is that its phase is reversed when you apply to it a rotation with angle 2pi. The content of a theory is usually specified by describing separately the physical states that are possible in the theory, known as its kinematics, and the rules that govern how one state evolves into another, or its dynamics. Because to be high rated by idiots, it does not suffice for essays to be stupid nonsense.
Here are the explanations. What does it mean? I would like you to consider the case of the Dirac equation.
On the FQXI math/physics essay contest
The FQXi essay competition entries are conrest for public viewing and feedback, resulting in lively online discussions between essay contributors and other members of the community. Of course a corollary is that idiots, with their own bias, will filter information according to their own biases, and will skip the sane reviews.
It cannot come from the scientific quality of his essay, since it is only a relative quality with some flaws as I pointed outbut even more esday because, as demonstrated by the community ratings of the rest of essays in this contest, community rating generally has nothing to do with scientific quality anyway.
But where does the problem come from? Many cobtest claim to “explain” the remarkable role of maths and physics by the assumption that it does not exist, i.
Mind makes collapse after decoherence This contest: His misunderstanding is to insist on the fact that institutional habits and fqxii review can be biased, which essat also happen in principle, but which is only one side of things; he does not seem to measure the real extent to which science does need a filter to survive in an ocean of bad ideas from amateurs.
Because naively implemented, such a method will fail in a world with a ratio of 10 idiots for 1 competent reviewer, as long as no system is developed ckntest people to automatically filter the information depending on the competence of the reviewer. Mind makes collapse before decoherence H. On the contrary, scientific quality would be rather a handicap in this rating.
The independent Institute was founded in to foster breakthroughs in the fundamental understanding of our universe, from the smallest particles to the entire contet. Maudlin as expressed elsewhere. FQXi is a non-profit organization that supports the investigation of fundamental questions in physics and cosmology, through grants and the burgeoning essay contest.
Everyone his own opinion.